The Standing Army
Live
Equipment

Court orders Navy to re-evaluate Saildrone MUSV bid

A federal court ruled the U.S. Navy unfairly excluded Saildrone from a $2.1 billion unmanned vessel competition, ordering a 60-day reevaluation and blocking over $1.5 billion in program spending until it complies.

A federal court ruled the U.S. Navy unfairly excluded Saildrone from a $2.1 billion unmanned vessel competition, ordering...

A federal judge has ruled the U.S. Navy violated procurement rules by unfairly excluding Saildrone from the competition for its Medium Unmanned Surface Vessel (MUSV) program. The Court of Federal Claims found the Navy's evaluation was arbitrary and capricious, ordering a new review of Saildrone's proposal within 60 days and barring the service from committing more than $1.5 billion of the program's $2.1 billion budget until it does so.

Judge Philip Hadji ruled that Saildrone was unlawfully excluded from the MUSV competition. The court determined the Navy engaged in disparate treatment, applying standards to Saildrone it did not use for other bidders. Saildrone was eliminated after the Navy cited discrepancies between its proposal and a document called a J-8 Placemat regarding maximum displacement. The company was initially deemed non-compliant across all three evaluation criteria.

Saildrone challenged the decision. The Navy subsequently abandoned two of its three non-compliance determinations. The court rejected the remaining one, concluding the Navy used arbitrary criteria not applied elsewhere in the competition.

Navy barred from spending beyond $1.5 billion until reevaluation

The ruling imposes a significant financial constraint on the MUSV program. The Navy cannot commit additional funds beyond $1.5 billion until it completes the court-ordered reevaluation of Saildrone's bid. This restriction applies to the program's total budget of $2.1 billion. The judge's decision was issued on Monday, according to a Saildrone press release. The Navy must conduct the new evaluation before moving forward with major financial commitments for production.

Saildrone and Blue Water Autonomy sued over exclusion

Saildrone was not the only company to legally challenge the Navy's MUSV selection process. Both Saildrone and Blue Water Autonomy filed separate lawsuits in June contesting their eliminations. Saildrone had proposed its Spectre vessel, while Blue Water Autonomy offered the Liberty. The court's recent ruling specifically addresses Saildrone's case. It upheld the Navy's disqualification of Blue Water Autonomy.

Court mandated equal evaluation criteria for all competitors

The judge's order mandates a fair reassessment. The Navy must reevaluate Saildrone's proposal using the exact same standards applied to other companies that advanced in the competition. It is prohibited from relying on its previously withdrawn findings under the other two evaluation criteria to eliminate Saildrone again. The court clarified that the solicitation's requirement for a 'representative' test vessel unambiguously called for a comparison between the test vessel and the production vessel. It stated the solicitation did not exclude hull form or propulsion architecture from that comparison. The ruling was originally issued on October 30 and was publicly released the following Wednesday. The Navy must complete its reevaluation of Saildrone's proposal within 60 days using consistent evaluation criteria applied to all competitors.

Related coverage

More from Equipment